Insurance agency web design

Websites for insurance companies that turn visitors into quotes.

Carriers, MGAs, brokerages, and the insurtech platforms behind them come to Takeoff when the insurance website stops matching the business. We rebuild it around how buyers shop coverage, with a design built to generate leads rather than list products.

Book a Call

See the work

The pattern

Where web design for insurance usually goes wrong

Most of these sites were built once, for compliance sign-off, not for how people actually shop for coverage today.

What brings insurance teams to us

Competitors with less insurance expertise winning the organic traffic and AI mentions

Coverage listed as a product menu, with nothing explaining who each one is for

A quote or contact path buried three clicks from where buyers land

An insurance website that breaks on a phone, where most of the traffic now lands

What we do about it

Reporting tied to quote requests and lead generation, not website visits

A redesign built around how your target audience actually shops coverage

Responsive design that holds up on every screen, tested before launch

SEO and AEO work so the insurance business shows up where buyers start

I've been through 12 website launches in my career and I want to give some well-deserved credit to Takeoff for delivering the best experience I've had to date.

Kristine Champion · SVP Marketing, AuthenticID

Overview

Insurance website design for the companies modernizing insurance

Insurance is being rebuilt from the inside, and the companies doing it are selling into carriers, brokers and MGAs who move carefully and buy by committee.

That means the site has to do more than describe the product. It has to prove the thing underwriting, IT, compliance and procurement each need proven before anyone books a demo. We look at what those buyers search, what they need to see before they'll take a meeting, and where the current site loses them.

We handle strategy, design, development and SEO on one team, and hand over a CMS your team can update without a developer.

Who it's for

Insurtech platforms selling to carriers, where the buyer is technical and the sale is long

Brokerages where insurance agents send prospects to a site that undercuts them

Carriers and MGAs whose insurance agency websites were built for a different product line

Insurance brands whose digital presence is invisible in the search and AI results where buyers compare

Case studies

Insurance results

This service in action.

Duck Creek

P&C Insurance Software

114.63%

LLM-sourced sessions post-launch

23.37%

Website traffic increase post-launch

48.3%

Target keywords on page 1 within 45 days of launch

Check out the Site

Core Deliverables

What an insurance website redesign includes

The concrete deliverables, start to launch. CMS-agnostic by design

Strategy & discovery

Stakeholder workshops, persona research, competitive analysis, KPI definition and a full site audit. You leave with one metric everyone has agreed to.

UX design

Information architecture, user journey mapping, unlimited wireframe iterations and CRO work.

Visual design

Three homepage concepts from three designers, then responsive design across every breakpoint. Designed with real copy rather than lorem ipsum.

Development & CMS

A modular CMS on Webflow, HubSpot, WordPress, Craft or Drupal, with content migration, training and CRM integration. We are a Webflow Certified Partner, and you own everything from day one.

Migration & SEO

A 55-point redirect map, keyword research and an SEO roadmap, so organic traffic survives the launch and grows after it.

Launch & measurement

Pre-launch audit, launch support, 30-day monitoring, and reporting tied to qualified pipeline rather than sessions.

Want an insurance website that generates leads? Let's talk.

Book a call

Results

Proof from B2B brands

Measured across organic visibility, qualified inquiries, and pipeline.

+250%

Demo requests from search · ServiceTrade

+226.7%

Contact form submissions · Glenmede

+57.1%

SEO-sourced demo requests · FiscalNote

+637%

AI search sessions · StreetLight

Industries

Other industries we serve

Every industry buys differently. Explore the work we do in others.

Financial Services

Healthcare

Enterprise

VC and Private Equity

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the essential core features of insurance web design?

Five, in the order they matter. A clear path to a quote or a conversation from every page. Coverage explained by who it is for rather than listed as a product menu. Responsive design that works on a phone, where most insurance traffic now lands. Licensing, disclosures and carrier appointments handled as content your team can update. And SEO and AEO built into the rebuild, so organic traffic survives the launch and the insurance company shows up in AI answers.

A standard project runs about 14 weeks.

What makes Takeoff different from other web design agencies for insurance?

We build for a long, multi-stakeholder decision, which is what insurance buying actually is. Strategy and page map come before design, three designers produce independent concepts, and SEO and AEO sit inside the rebuild rather than after it. Licensing, disclosures and carrier appointments are handled as content your team controls.

We've done this work for Duck Creek and bolttech, and you own the files and the code from day one.

What should you look for when choosing an insurance web design company?

Ask whether they've handled licensing, disclosures and carrier appointments as content before, or whether that becomes your problem after launch. Ask how they protect organic traffic through the migration. Ask whether your team can update coverage pages and agent listings without a developer.

And ask who writes the copy, because insurance content is where generic agencies get exposed.

Do you work with independent agencies, or only carriers and insurtech?

Both. Carriers and insurtech platforms are most of the work, including Duck Creek and bolttech, but independent agencies and brokers hit the same problems on a smaller site: coverage explained as a product menu, no clear path to a quote, and no visibility in search.

The scope scales down, and a retainer is often the better starting point for a smaller agency.

Do we have to do a full redesign to work with you?

No. An ongoing optimization retainer is often the smarter first move. We improve the site in pieces, so you spend less up front and results tend to show up sooner because work ships as it's ready.

It fits sites that are structurally fine and mainly need conversion work and search visibility.

Will a redesign put our organic traffic at risk?

That's the main risk in any replatform, so migration gets planned before design starts: URL mapping, redirects, metadata and schema carried across, then monitoring after launch. SEO is part of the rebuild rather than a phase after it.

Glenmede came out of their project with a 108.59% increase in non-branded traffic.

How long does an insurance website redesign take?

About 14 weeks, with a range of 12 to 16 depending on scope. Compliance and carrier review usually move the number more than design does, so those are scheduled as named stages up front.

Multi-line carriers with several products and regions sit at the top of the range.

What does insurance agency website design cost?

The growth package starts at $50k and enterprise at $130k. Page count, how many lines of coverage need their own pages, content migration, and integrations like quote tools or agent locators are what move the number.

Retainers are priced separately if you'd rather spread the work out.

Can you improve our visibility when buyers ask AI assistants who to call?

Yes, and it's part of the build. We structure pages so answer engines can extract a clean answer, mark up the company, its coverage lines and its licensed locations, and build the third-party citations these models pull from.

Glenmede's LLM-sourced contact requests went up 828.57%, and StreetLight's AI search sessions went up 637%.

How do you handle licensing, disclosures, and carrier appointments?

As content types rather than hardcoded text. Licensed states, carrier appointments and required disclosures live in the CMS, so when something changes your team updates it in one place and every page that references it updates too.

That also means state-specific pages and agent listings can be generated instead of built by hand.